Phase 1 Pre-BIS
This will be updated after raids release and we know exactly what we're dealing with.
To prepare for Phase 1 raids, we're mostly focusing on becoming uncrittable. This means we need to reach 440 total defense (300 base defense + 140 defense from gear/talents). With 20 defense available from anticipation, we need to find 120 more across our gear. With lower item budgets on pre-raid gear, this means we need defense on the majority of our slots. There are many ways you can build a pre-raid BIS set, so don't feel like you absolutely have to have every piece I suggest in my set. The general priority to go for a single target boss is Uncrittable > enough Stam to live > Hit Cap (8% for bosses) > Expertise Soft Cap (6.5% for bosses) > Spell Power > Crit. If you're gearing for pure survivability prio 440 Defense (uncritable) > Stam > Armor > Block > Defense beyond 440 > Parry > Dodge.
Once
Wild Leather Armor Kit is available, you can use these to add in more pieces without Defense across your set.
When
Initiate's Signet of Vigilance becomes available, that will be an automatic add.
Phase 1 Budget Pre-BIS Set
Compared to the much more expensive Blacksmithing variant, this set sims almost identical in single target threat, only a little lower in multi target threat, and loses a few hundred HP. But you save thousands of gold from not leveling Blacksmithing and crafting all of its BOP pieces. The majority of this set is obtained by simply spamming Scholomance, and you'll make a lot of gold while you do it. With 22 raid bosses in the first tier, you're also likely to replace Pre-BIS gear extremely quickly, so investment in your Pre-BIS set should be relatively low. I recommend this set or a similar one for anyone who isn't competing for a world first raid clear. The value gained from the Blacksmithing set is miniscule compared to its cost.
Cleansed Vilebranch Medallion sims slightly better than
Cleansed Vilebranch Icon for bosses due to the hit and also offers more consistent threat. It's likely the Hyjal Summit raid will count as a Forest, so you should get the bonus effect.
If you're willing to farm Alterac Valley rep, you can use the
Don Julio's Band instead of the
Cutthroat's Signet, but it will be a pretty big time investment.
If you have gold to get
Stalwart Helm, you can replace the defense with
Redoubt Cloak.
Sageblade is nearly identical to
Flurry Axe for single target, but a little better for multi target and has Stam. If you have a lot of gold, it's good, but
Flurry Axe is currently 1/5 the price.
Phase 1 Pre-BIS Set
If you're competing for world first or just love spending hours farming gold, this set or a similar one will be a little bit better than other options overall.