Build 1 (Full Tank - Armaments)
Any weapon that allows you to guard while attacking from behind the shield will always be one of your best options here, as it provides reliable damage output while keeping you safely behind cover
Mohgwyn's Sacred Spear
Dragon Halberd
Nightrider Glaive
Rotten Crystal Spear (just for scarlet rot procs)
Commander's Standard (Good for solid damage and gives out a buff to teammates increasing their armor and damage)
If you can't locate any of these weapons, make sure to keep an eye out for the best spear, halberd, or greatspear you can find or at least focus on upgrading your starting halberd to +2 by finding a
Smithing Stone [1] which can be bought from merchants and
Smithing Stone (2) from the mines if you can't find anything in the entire run.
Build 2 (Debuff Tank - Armaments)
Try your best to keep your starting weapon and upgrade it to the maximum as quickly as possible to maximize damage while maintaining your frostbite status with the Chilling Mist armament skill, which applies a damage resistance debuff to enemies, helping your teammates defeat them faster. You can also switch to other spears, halberds, or greatspears if you find it necessary, such as
Commander's Standard This will still provide your teammates with a buff instead of applying a debuff to enemies, which is also a viable option
Mohgwyn's Sacred Spear If you find it during the run and want to take advantage of its higher damage and constant bleed procs, switching to it is also a fair choice
(Both Builds - Shields)
Brass Shield
Fingerprint Stone Shield
Erdtree Greatshield
Crucible Hornshield These are all great options for high guard boost defensive shields. However, if none of them are available, keep an eye out for any other shield with a high guard boost ideally 70 or higher. If you can't find one, make sure to upgrade your default shield to +2 as soon as possible.
(Both Builds - Talismans)
Best-In-Slots
Green Turtle Talisman
Spear Talisman
Alternatives
Erdtree's Favor
Crimson Amber Medallion
Viridian Amber Medallion
Crimson Seed Talisman
Dragoncrest Shield Talisman
(Both Builds - Consumables)
Pickled Turtle Neck
Boiled Crab
Boiled Prawn
(Both Builds - Dormant Power)
HP Recovery upon Successful Guards
Increased Maximum HP
Increased Maximum Stamina
Improved Affinity Damage Negation
Improved Stamina Recovery