Free Action Potion
Free Action Potion (FAP) is your best friend as a warrior because it will drastically increase your uptime on enemies. This potion makes you immune to stuns, slows, and roots, which are all the main things that prevent melee classes from dealing damage. This will probably be your most-used consumable as a warrior, so stock up on them and make sure you have AT LEAST 5-10 of them before going into a battleground. Keep in mind that the buff this potion provides is purgable, so try to stack up as many "random" buffs from other classes/teammates, and even things like low-tier scrolls, as a way to protect your highly valuable FAP buff from getting purged.
Magic Dust
Magic Dust is an extremely powerful consumable that puts an enemy player to sleep for 30 seconds. This can be very useful in creating win conditions in battlegrounds, but keep in mind they will most likely be very expensive and will have to be used sparingly, unless you are very rich. It is probably unwise to use one on an Undead because they can break it with
Will of the Forsaken.
Thorium Grenade
Grenades are a must-have for warriors in PvP. They can be used in many different situations like creating a short window to connect to a target, interrupting a cast, or setting up a kill. They are especially useful against
Mage when they are trying to escape or get an important cast off on you - a well-timed grenade will completely change the tempo and outcome of the fight. The little bit of extra damage and stun from grenades is great for finishing off kills; however, keep in mind that the stun effect actually breaks to damage, so don't treat it as a guaranteed 3-second stun.
Heavy Runecloth Bandage
Warriors don't have any meaningful amount of self-healing other than
Victory Rush, so bandages are absolutely mandatory. A well timed
Intimidating Shout into a
Heavy Runecloth Bandage on yourself can be very effective, but keep in mind that you cannot bandage with dots on yourself, so keep an eye on your debuffs before using one.
Flash Bomb
Most enemy flag carriers in battlegrounds will be a
Druid, so using a
Flash Bomb on them while killing them is extremely powerful. As long as the druid is in
Bear Form or
Cat Form their character will be classified as a "beast" which is a requirement to use it.
Flash Bomb creates an effect similar to
Fear but it DOES NOT break on damage which is why it is so strong. If you and your team mates are all spamming
Flash Bomb on the enemy flag carrier, it will be a very scary moment for him.
Powerful Anti-Venom
Using an anti-venom while in a 1v1 situation vs a
Rogue is an extremely useful tool to prevent the "deadzone" strategy they use where they backpedal away from you with
Crippling Poison II on you, staying too far for you to attack, but not far enough for you to intercept (hence the term deadzone). Once you realize they are doing it to you, use the
Powerful Anti-Venom to dispel the
Crippling Poison II and get back in melee range and use
Rend to prevent them from getting back in
Stealth.
Major Discolored Healing Potion
Discolored Healing Potions are a massive self heal, but they have a major drawback which is putting either a disease or a poison on yourself. If poisoned you can use a
Powerful Anti-Venom to dispel it. If diseased you can use a "Powerful Poultice" but these can not be used in combat which can really suck.
Surgical Tourniquet
Tourniquets can be used to dispel bleeds off yourself which can have niche uses, but these can not be used in combat.
Whipper Root Tuber
Whipper Root Tuber are very useful because they are basically a 2nd health potion that doesn't share cooldown with normal health potions. You can gather them for free in Felwood.
Noggenfogger Elixir
Noggenfogger Elixir are great because they provide purge/dispel protection, which makes it harder for enemies to dispel your
Free Action Potion buff.
Slither Cord
Slither Cord is a great item to have because it dispels roots. It can be easily obtained in Wailing Caverns.
Skull Of Impending Doom
Skull of Impending Doom applies a damage-over-time effect on yourself which, if used preemptively, can break
Polymorph,
Blind, or
Freezing Trap. Using it in combination with a
Free Action Potion will make you immune to nearly everything. It also gives a 60% movement speed buff.
Reflector Trinkets
Gyrofreeze Ice Reflector,
Ultra-Flash Shadow Reflector,
Hyper-Radiant Flame Reflector can be very useful if used correctly.
They are pretty self-explanatory but
Gyrofreeze Ice Reflector should be used against a
Frost mage, or to immune a
Hunter's
Freezing Trap.
Ultra-Flash Shadow Reflector should be used against a
Warlock to counter their
Death Coil.
Hyper-Radiant Flame Reflector is probably the least useful out of the three, but it could be used against an
Elemental's
Lava Burst, or a
Fire
Mage.