Let’s start with Acolyte because we have more Passives revealed for this Ascendancy.
1. Chayula’s Gift
Effectiveness of this passive will be based on 2 things:
- How many monsters or bosses will do chaos damage in the game?
- Will we have items or keystones such as Divine Flesh or Incandescent Heart that will allow us to take some elemental or physical damage as chaos.
Based on those +10% maximum chaos resistance could be VERY strong or just an average bonus.
There is also a chance that it can double your negative resistance as well because it worked this way in POE1, if it will be this way in POE2 we will need to get Chaos Resistance to at least +1 out of -60%.
Also keep in mind that this passive is not stacking with Chaos Inoculation which makes you chaos immune - so more chaos resistance will give you nothing.
Should we take this passive or not will be up to the 2 points mentioned above, but it looks like a nice way to boost defenses for 2 points.
2. Ravenous Doubts
Is the passive which makes all mana leech instant and this is one of the reasons why Acolyte looks good.
Considering Monk had mana issues in almost all showcased versions this passive should help tremendously with mana sustain and could be naturally combined with Mind over Matter keystone which gives us All Damage Taken from mana Before Life providing an additional defensive layer.
In PoE 1, Eldritch Battery was a Keystone that converted your Energy Shield into Mana. It has been confirmed that Eldritch Battery will NOT be the same. Even still, there likely will be some synergy with Mana/ES, so keep an eye out for that.
3. Consuming Questions
Combined with Ravenous Doubts it "should" make Energy shield recovery from mana leech instant as well which is going to help with ES sustain giving us 3 layers of defense: ES, Mana and Life.
For most Hybrid builds with Energy Shield that passive looks like a must because it will be easier to boost only Mana Leech instead of trying to get sources for both + making it Instant is a strong bonus.
? Embrace the Darkness
This removes ALL the spirit, so you can't use reservation skills anymore which is a big downside and provides up to 600 Darkness (at level 100) which could protect your life and ES against damage becoming an additional layer of defense.
This passive works very well with Mind Over Matter again since it protects your Life and ES and would combine greatly with Ravenous Doubts.
It does not sound that good initially since the downside is pretty big, but it stacks well with next passives in line.
4. Waking Dream
Provides Into the Breach skill, which gives the chance to drop flames of Chayula which grants life, mana and damage.
Unfortunately we don't have enough info about amounts those flames can provide and it needs to be confirmed if we can spawn those on bosses but the skill itself looks decent enough to consider since it can help with recovery and damage at the same time.
It also leads to an unidentified passive which is yet to be revealed.
5. Grasp of the Void
Gives 1% of damage as extra chaos for 20 unreserved darkness.
So when nothing is hitting you it will give up to 30% of additional damage as Chaos at the maximum. (At level 100)
It can add Chaos damage to ANY other type of damage including chaos itself, so conversion there is pretty simple.
There is also 1 more Passive connected to Embrace the Darkness and for now it is unknown, but I would expect it to interact with darkness mechanics in some fashion too.
Generally both Embrace the Darkness and Grasp the Void look pretty average, 30% bonus damage and some defensive layer is better in POE2 than in POE1 but losing spirit completely and spending 4 Ascendency points for it looks like a heavy gamble.
We will need to see other passives to decide if those 2 are worth it or we will have better options, but I hope we will have better ones and will try to avoid these myself.